“Driver Sought In Hit-and-Run; Victim Critical”, read the headline in the Daily Oklahoman on May 2, 1990. The newspaper reported that police were still searching for the driver of a car that had struck 22-year-old Tonya Dawn Hughes a week earlier on a service road near a major highway in Oklahoma City.
That isn’t the type of incident usually explored in a true-crime film, but the story went far deeper, as chronicled in the chilling Netflix documentary The Girl in the Picture, which has been atop the most-watched movies on the streaming platform since it premiered last week.
Even the original 12-paragraph Oklahoman article made the story seem simple, if sad, noting that Hughes had been staying at a nearby motel with her husband, Clarence Hughes, and their son, Michael,…