TO MAKE THEIR HOUSE A HOME, Joey Meyers and Mark Baehser had to go through a long, challenging process of downsizing—but not in the way you’d expect.
In 2015, Meyers, who worked in the food industry, and Baehser, a pediatrician, were living in a 500-square-foot rental in Brooklyn and searching, in vain, for a comparable space nearby they could afford to purchase. When desperation brought the couple across the river to Jersey City, New Jersey, they ended up falling for a 3,500-square-foot freestanding 1880s Victorian with striking stained-glass windows, three floors, and five bedrooms.
Drunk on all that newfound space and short on furnishings to fill it, Meyers began indulging his longtime thrifting obsession. Before long, “Every room in the house was piled high with furniture and lamps and tchotchkes…