There’s no bigger stage for an athlete than the Big Apple. Here, by decade, we boldly present Esquire’s list of the superstars—some larger-than-life, many of them Yankees—who have reigned supreme in the city over the past century. Let the debates begin.
1920S
Babe Ruth, Yankees Jack Dempsey, heavyweight champ
1930S
Lou Gehrig, Yankees
Joe Louis, heavyweight champ
1940S
Joe DiMaggio, Yankees
Jackie Robinson, Dodgers
1950S
Willie Mays, Giants (baseball)
Mickey Mantle, Yankees
Frank Gifford, Giants
1960S
Joe Namath, Jets
Tom Seaver, Mets
1970S
Walt Frazier, Knicks
Reggie Jackson, Yankees
1980S
Dwight Gooden & Darryl Strawberry, Mets
Lawrence Taylor, Giants
Don Mattingly, Yankees
1990S
Patrick Ewing, Knicks
Mark Messier, Rangers
2000S
Derek Jeter, Yankees
2010S
Eli Manning, Giants
Jacob DeGrom, Mets
2020S
Aaron Judge, Yankees…
