Let’s get the spoilers out of the way: Bruce Willis is dead, Sam Jackson is the villain, water is the aliens’ weakness, Giamatti is the healer, the village exists in modern times, and, now, Becca and Tyler’s grandparents aren’t really their grandparents. The twist, of which M. Night Shyamalan is known to be cinema’s most indulgent purveyor, is the signature ploy of a director whose surface-level intention is to impress audiences with his ability to manipulate them like a bunko magician.
Beginning with The Sixth Sense, Shyamalan’s penchant for third-act revelations has never subsided, but henceforth they emerged less as shocks and more as inevitabilities, not emphasized for how well hidden they were, but for what they meant emotionally. Casting himself in cameos a la Hitchcock, Shyamalan is partly responsible…