IN an autumn and winter of mega Nearctic vagrants, Holboell’s Red-necked Grebe won’t fill many birder’s headline slots – but one at Quendale Bay, Shetland, from 5-15 February, is undoubtedly one of the rarest birds to be found during the American bonanza.
Only in-hand measurements can definitively separate the North American and East Asian holboellii form of Red-necked Grebe, which has occurred only once in Britain and sits in Category B owing to a single specimen record from Gruinard Bay, Highland, in September 1925. More recently, birds have appeared in France and Iceland. A credible British claim off Barra, Outer Hebrides, from January-March 2018, was only documented in the field and thus couldn’t make the grade.
The Shetland bird’s appearance was certainly suggestive of holboellii. The bird’s large, thickset bill,…
